On my initial viewing of the unit on 3/27, Nick Kedrowski told me that the well water was “clean & good.”
On that same day, he also claimed that the unit’s pipes were being replaced to improve the water pressure and the job would be completed by “mid-May” though he wrote the lease to say just May.
Nick omitted from our conversation on 3/27 that while the well water was 'clean & good' - the water in the unit was not because it was full of iron - way
way
over the EPA GRAS
of 0.3ppm.
Nowhere in any of the emails exchanged between
3/24-4/26
did Nick provide any information re the gross problem with iron in the water. See #1 in heading.
4/16 Nick omitted the iron-water issue from our conversation on 3/27 & subsequent emails through 4/15 as part of the reason the pipes were being replaced. The new pipes weren’t about only the
water pressure as Nick later confirmed (below 5/10) after he received my email of 5/10 describing the water. The iron may well have been the sole reason given the minimal to no improvement in water
pressure. I
signed the lease on 4/16 without the information necessary to make an informed decision. Had I known of the iron problem I would have made a different decision & moved instead to one
of the other locations I was considering. See #3 in heading.
4/27 It was only after I moved in on 4/27 that I discovered the enormous amount of iron in the water when I viewed the
two toilet bowls
for the first time and drew water from each of the taps. Other issues,
door & windows, especially were noted on move-in.
5/02 - 5/08 Cash job/No permit plumber, Kurt, showed up a couple times to begin replacing the unit's water pipes
5/10 After several visits over the next 10 days, Spectrum finally achieved a mostly stable internet connection and I was finally able to write to Nick on
5/10 (excerpt follows):
"I’m also quite concerned re the water as it continues to be orange rather than the usual clear as seen in the picture of the toilet bowl. It is particularly disconcerting that the orange water
morphs into particles that land on the bottom of the glass. An explanation and rectification of this situation is necessary."
and "I do think functioning doors, windows & screens, clear water, etc., are rather reasonable expectations."
Nick replied that he was unaware of the unit's condition on 5/10. Perhaps he thinks that makes him immune to the legal requirements of WI §704. It doesn't.
Nick evinced no surprise at all that the amount of iron in the unit's water was a problem: “The water issues must be related to the pipes in the trailer itself and the
new lines should remedy that.” Note: "must be" & "should remedy that"
5/11 Nick & Joey showed up with no appointment at the unit. Nick apologized, reduced the rent for May, held the plate that had fallen off the door & said "the door has to be replaced." He said
that the kitchen flooring needed repair.
5/11- 5/18 Plumber no shows all week. Texted him that I had no hot water on 5/18 - texts 5/11 - 6/17
5/19 Plumber showed up to fix the hot water problem; said he would tell Nick the water was still orange.
5/20 I sent a list of repairs thinking maybe the 20 page pdf of 5/10 was too much, somehow, for them to cope with.
5/21 Nick & Joey tacked screen fabric over the torn, missing, and/or holey screens - 5 of 10 windows. No interior access required; no conversation.
5/31 Last time the plumber showed up at my unit; this time to remove old water heater. He said he forgot to hook up outdoor water tap & that he'd tell Nick water was still orange.
6/02 Texted plumber to ask when he was coming back for outdoor tap & whatever else remained to be done.
6/05 Plumber was arrested for felony stalking a woman in Stevens Point. 6/05, he texted
me, "Promise to get it hooked up tomorrow I've been out last couple days with my back."
On 6/06, he texted: "Will be here bed ridden for one more day because they will only give me shot, not painkillers."
He was In court from jail on 6/13.
Mid-June Joey & Delbert showed up 20 minutes late to place stick on tiles over the torn linoleum. Joey said he overslept.
6/17 I texted a picture of the morning's water
to plumber. I had no idea what was going on with him at the time so I waited a bit to see if he'd show up or text or ?? I had found his attitude & demeanor
disconcerting & had been afraid he'd show up when I wasn't there. He had left the panel of the back of the bathtub plumbing allowing my 16 yr old 100% indoor cat to escape for three days. Again,
when he showed up & wouldn't give me a moment to lock down the cats, he panicked & escaped again for another day. My temporary insurance license to work in Wisconsin expired the next day.
Now, I can't work in Minnesota or Wisconsin as a result of waiting for the skeevy no-show/cash job plumber since May 2 (47 days). He was arrested
for burglary & misappropriation of ID later,
6/20 I went to the Water Quality store to obtain an evaluation of the amount of iron in the water. Result 20.0ppm; EPA GRAS 0.3ppm; 6667% over GRAS & here. I could have gone
to Home Depot for an OTC test, but wanted an independent third party to do the test.
6/30 I wrote again
to Nick, "I am pretty far beyond merely “disappointed” at this point. Please see pages 3-5 re orange water, not finished pipes. I waited day after day for Kurt to show up – to no avail."
The email continued with the repairs that had not been done: "There seems to be very little interest in completing the tasks that were to be completed before I relocated and since you were
notified of the various problems 5/10. It is now seven weeks since 5/10."
Trying to open the door results in swollen wrist, have to slam shoulder
in to it; the temperature in the unit was 90° &
they will address problems "
soon"; stairs were to be replaced
spring or summer
(replaced w/not to code/no permit stairs on 9/11).
He then provided his definition of the problem & their solution:
If the water remains unimproved, it may be necessary to replace lines below ground. We will determine how best to approach that situation if the need arises but if that is the case, we may
have to terminate your lease because we would not continue to rent the unit
until that issue is remedied...." NOTE: "IF" the water remains unimproved..." How would that happen without intervention?
"replace lines below ground" = Definition of problem Definition of their solution: "we may have to terminate your lease" "would not continue to rent the unit until the issue is remedied..."
They have defined the problem & solution: kick out the old lady who had signed a one-year lease 63 days earlier & moved herself & two cats two hundred miles to expand her insurance brokerage.
Any requests ever to evaluate the problem? No.
They chose not to share the information about underground lines with me & the iron problem at anytime from the initial email of 3/24 to the 4/12 email which provided the one year lease.
Had I known the problem AND the fact that they had no intention whatsoever of correcting the problem(s), I would have made a different decision.
Advertising the unit as "available now" on 3/24 with no intention to correct the problem(s) known to them and renting it without supplying that information to gain a rent-paying tenant is fraud.
Their demand for full rent without making ANY of the necessary repairs makes this an egregious fraud.
I wrote again
to refute his accusation that I hadn't answered phone calls or texts and wrote that my communication would be by email.
7/03
Nick's email
states "Our primary concern is the water quality at your unit and that will take priority for us, if that can't be corrected the other issues are moot. While I am here I will be
coordinating with Delbert and establish a schedule to address everything." Ok - water quality is priority. Good. Wait, what?? IF
that CAN'T
be corrected??? ...the other issues are moot???
Note: Considering other repairs "moot" because you don't want to do a particular repair is in violation of §704.07. Nevertheless, I conclude that their next step is to address the water quality.
Bring on the inspection, evaluation, assessment, right?
Yeah, none of that was requested, none of it happened.
NONE of the repairs detailed in my 5/10 email have been completed or half-done so, of course, he demands full rent for August. Do I have "full normal use" of the unit? No. Have the structural repairs
7/07 I went again to the Water Quality store to obtain an evaluation of the amount of iron in the water. Result 8.0ppm; EPA GRAS 0.3ppm; 2667% over GRAS & here. I could have gone
to Home Depot for an OTC test, but wanted an independent third party to do the test.
7/16
Thirteen days later, Joey & Delbert showed up without tools, without a list or pdf of what needed to be done, & stood in the kitchen looking around like they'd never seen the place.
I assumed they were there to figure out why the water was still pouring iron out of every single tap. But, no. I directed them to the full bathroom where I had displayed water from the previous
few days shown on the home page of this site &
here. They stood there, looked at the water, said not one word, turned & walked away. I'm flabbergasted, but think - 20 year old boy & a
vehicle mechanic. They'll talk to Nick and get back to me on this priority issue. In the meantime, I loaned Delbert a screwdriver to see if he could get one of the living room windows to open.
Joey fetched a drill that enabled Delbert to open the window. Then, it couldn't be closed. Joey put a pin in the door hinge so it wouldn't fall off again & had his Uncle Delbert check his work.
Delbert chuckled at the way I had to open the back door with a shoulder slam. He looked at tile “repair” that had come undone to the stick-on floor tiles due to gap under door (rain, no
screen door) & said he “thought that would probably happen.”
Then, they were gone and I was off to an appointment to look at another place to live having researched "constructive eviction.'
So, what did Nick do about the water problem after Joey & Delbert reported back to him? Did he ask for an appointment to assess or evaluate the cause of the problem? No. That was never done
because he had already defined the problem as the underground pipes (
7/01) & they were
not
going to do that. If they had done this responsibly and in accord with Wisconsin laws, he would have
had the new pipes replaced to determine whether that corrected the quantity of iron flowing from every tap in the house, and then and only then, determined whether to rent the unit.
8/05 I heard nothing about anything from anyone at Five Skies since 7/16 - 21 days. I found a recommendation on the Tenant Resource Center's (Madison, WI) website to submit a written request for
the
date that repairs would be completed. I dropped it in the same mail slot that all rent checks were deposited in along with my acceptance of their offer to pay rent in sync with my social security
some wouldn't open, some wouldn't close and no a/c in unit. I continued my search to accomplish my constructive eviction.
8/08 Went back to Water Quality store for iron quantity tests- begin shower at 6.00ppm (not 0.3ppm); end of shower at 2.00ppm (not 0.3ppm). Results
here. My search for another place to live continued.
8/15 I paid rent as agreed per Joey's email
re in sync with my social security check. I paid FULL rent despite fact that NO repairs described in 5/10
email had been accomplished: not the door, not the
windows, and not the horrendous water. I had heard not ONE word from them about doing any of the repairs since 7/16: 31 days. Receipt:
no late fees, zero balance due.
8/22 Septic pipe broke/disconnected
at back end of neighbor's unit. Sewage began spewing from the pipe on my lawn. Brief encouner with Joey: stairs to be replaced "hopefully Labor Day weekend,"
and he is looking at back doors (again).
8/24 Cash-job plumber supposedly reconnected the two pipes.
8/30 Kurt returned to fiddle with the pipe & left. Sewage continued to spew.
9/03 Sent
letter to Five Skies
including statement that sewage had been on my lawn since 8/22. Advised I would contact appropriate gov't agencies; pursue legal action if repairs not remedied within
one week. It had been 3 months & 25 days since initial notification of 5/10.
9/06 My letter to Five Skies LLC was
received
via USPS priority mail.
9/08 18 days since 8/22: plumber returned to hose the sewage into my lawn. He did not apply bleach as required by DSPS. Sewage spill was not reported to DSPS as required.
He hooked up the outdoor water tap on my unit. This is the water that flowed from the tap after he left.